This is certainly an Ebay fail. I guess you get what you pay for? I mean I would pay full price for NARS if I knew it was safe for me to use. Just because there isn’t bad ingredients listed doesn’t mean that my skin will be okay with it.
Anyways, the listing said new but you can tell it’s been used. The packaging even looks old and there’s tarnished edges around the purple one. Unfortunately this is an Ebay fail.